A comment on ADHD as “the Erectile Dysfunction of the Mind”

A comment on ADHD as “the Erectile Dysfunction of the Mind”

“I do not have the interest. Therefore I cannot do it.”

The above statement can be… troublesome. This time it comes in the form of a metaphor: that ADHD is “the erectile dysfunction of the mind.”

While there is some truth to the post, I do worry how it might lead to a slippery slope of victimhood and helplessness if we’re not careful.

When we place the blame solely on “chemistry”, something beyond our “willpower,” we hit troubles, not just from the statement, but as both words can carry tremendous baggage.

On Chemistry

The example of erectile dysfunction itself, highlights some of the problems. While a person can have troubles performing because of illness, age, or more, they might also struggle because of emotional troubles within the relationship.

Certainly, make medical visits to assess difficulties there.  But there might also be benefit in acknowledging the frustration and potential meaning of the dysfunction. Doing so might lead to examining those relationship troubles, and then making own decisions about what to do about them, whether that is a change of communication style, lifestyle, or the relationship itself.

In one sense, everything can be reduced to chemistry. For example carbon, oxygen, and hydrogen make up a tremendous part of our universe, within and beyond ourselves.

But chemistry is an epiphenomena of physics. And, biology is an epiphenomenon of chemistry. Why stop here? Isn’t the mind an epiphenomena of brain? Why discount the validity of meaning, story, and by extension our very sense of existence?

In this way, the claim that chemistry is the only means of understanding risks eroding our sense of free will and that we might be able to do something about our condition.

On Willpower vs Agency

“Willpower” is a problematic word—often suggesting force, a binary state, and ignores the multiple emotional fields at play. Even when we say, “I don’t want to do the dishes,” there’s a part of us that does. Otherwise the conversation wouldn’t even exist to begin with.

I much prefer the concept of agency: the ability to decide and engage non-reactively. When our agency is injured—when we lose, forget, or can’t engage—we lose trust in ourselves.

Healing agency means learning to decide and engage without force, honoring our emotions, not just the loudest ones. Agency becomes *a skill we can practice*, rather than a binary question of “do we have willpower or not?”

Practice, in turn, isn’t about force or pain. It’s about care—clearing and supporting paths for what’s meaningful.

When we show up to something to allow that self that arrives to make their own decisions about whether to do something or not, we are practicing a Visit.

When we do so daily, we build momentum, in honoring our desires, respecting our present and future selves, as well as whatever direction we head. We guide our the waves of emotion and focus within ourselves, using our own rhythms. We practice agency.

– Kourosh

PS I’m putting together a longer version of this piece as Episode 15 of Rhythms of Focus. Subscribe to the podcast to get it when it comes out.

Join the Weekly Wind Down Newsletter

Get a weekly letter about getting to play and meaningful work. Start getting where you want to be with calm focus. You’ll receive free samples of:

  • Creating Flow with OmniFocus
  • Taking Smart Notes with DEVONthink
  • Workflow Mastery
  • PDF on beating deadlines with ease using the Touching the Keys Technique

Recent Posts

One is King

One is King

Taking my piano teacher’s advice and once again applying it to productivity.

read more
There’s No Difference Between Task and Appointments?!

There’s No Difference Between Task and Appointments?!

While some productivity experts advocate scheduling tasks like appointments, this approach doesn’t work for everyone, especially those engaged in creative work. This article explores the limitations of rigid time-blocking and introduces the concept of a “Visit” as an alternative measure of work, emphasizing the power of showing up and then deciding.

read more
ADHD – Victims and Survivors

ADHD – Victims and Survivors

Is ADHD real? It seems like everyone has it now. What symptom isn’t ADHD? Isn’t it over-diagnosed? In a lively 4th of July discussion, these questions sparked a deeper conversation about agency, personal responsibility, and the power of self-determination. Discover how reframing our understanding of agency can transform our approach to mental health and productivity.

read more
On the Word “Harmony”

On the Word “Harmony”

The term "harmony" finds its way into many places. But I worry if its power has dissolved, diluted among commerce and culture. But a pause brings its beauty and power from whatever had once obscured it, never truly lost, patiently awaiting an observer, should we ever...

read more
Skip to content